SafeChoice Insurance Company

SafeChoice Insurance Company

SafeChoice Insurance Company (formerly SureChoice) was founded to deliver stability, security and first-class service to New York homeowners protecting their most valuable asset. SafeChoice is highly rated by Demotech and offers dependable homeowners (HO-3) and dwelling fire (DP-3) coverage in New York. These highly competitive products have Coverage A limits up to $2,000,000 and maximum liability coverage up to $1,000,000.

SageSure’s Partnership with SafeChoice Insurance Company

SageSure serves as the program manager and servicing agent for SafeChoice, providing all customer service, policy processing, claims servicing and other operating support.

SafeChoice’s Financial Strength

SafeChoice has a Financial Stability Rating of A, Exceptional, from Demotech, Inc., a financial analysis firm that has been providing financial stability ratings since 1985.

SafeChoice homeowners insurance products from SageSure

New York Homeowners

Homeowners coverage is offered statewide.

New Customers

How do I get homeowners insurance with SafeChoice?

If you live in New York, contact a local agent or broker and ask for SafeChoice homeowners insurance through SageSure.

Existing Customers

What do I do if I have a claim?

Report a claim 24/7 online at  or by calling (866)-311-7243.

How can I make a payment?

Access your policy and make fast, secure payments online anytime at


To pay by check, please send your payment to:

SageSure Insurance Managers, LLC

PO Box 896671

Charlotte, NC 28289-6671

Your insurance agent can also accept your payment in person or over the phone.

How can I make a policy change?

Your agent (listed on your policy declarations page) is your best resource for policy changes or any questions you may have. If you need further assistance, contact SageSure Customer Care at (800) 481-0337.